If imaging shows the inside,

what exactly is the "outwardly reflected picture"?

 

The Organon Letter — Issue #16

A question about Aphorism 7 that an endosonography report made me ask.

 

Hi and Welcome!

 

There is something fascinating about the language we use in medicine. We speak of the internal and the external, the visible and the invisible, the disease and its manifestations. Yet the more sophisticated our diagnostic tools become, the more I question whether we have ever fully understood what we mean by these words.

I recently came across an endosonography report that made me pause. Not because endosonography is new, but because it was the first time in my clinical life that I had encountered such a report, and I found myself looking at it through a different lens.

Structures once inaccessible to our eyes can now be visualised, measured and documented. It is an extraordinary extension of our clinical senses.

Then I remembered Hahnemann.

— ES

 

3 INSIGHTS

  1. Which of these is internal, and which is external?

    In Aphorism 7, Hahnemann directs us to the totality of symptoms as the outwardly reflected picture of the internal essence of the disease.

    Here begins my dilemma. If this is the outwardly reflected picture, how far does the internal extend? And if imaging shows us the internal, what is the outwardly reflected picture?

    Is the anatomical lesion the internal essence of disease, or is it another outward manifestation, observed through a more sophisticated instrument?

     

  2. Perhaps "internal" has two meanings.

    There is the anatomical internal: the structures, tissues, organs and pathological alterations within the body. And there is the deeper internal, the disease as a disturbance of the living organism in its entirety.

    The first can be visualised, measured and documented. The second is approached through the totality of its manifestations.

    A diagnostic image reveals the location, dimensions and structure of a lesion. It does not tell us everything about the patient's experience of being ill. The patient's symptoms reveal a great deal about the disturbance of the organism, but not its precise anatomical location. These are not competing pictures. They are different windows onto the same human being.

     

  3. Do not confuse the reflection with the object.

    In our enthusiasm to understand the internal essence of disease, we may have overlooked the phrase outwardly reflected. A reflection is not the object itself. It is the appearance of the object through a particular medium.

    The art of clinical medicine lies in neither confusing the reflection with the object, nor dismissing the reflection because we have found something deeper anatomically.

    An imaging report tells us what the instrument has revealed. A patient tells us what the disease has made of their life. The physician must learn to listen to both.

2 RESOURCES

  1. Organon §6 and §7, read side by side

    Read both aphorisms slowly, and note exactly which words each uses for what the physician perceives and what lies behind it. Then ask where an imaging report belongs in that chain. Does it extend what the physician perceives, or does it stand outside it?

     

  2. Arthur Kleinman, The Illness Narratives (1988)

    Kleinman distinguishes disease, the physician's account of a pathological alteration, from illness, the patient's lived experience of it. An imaging report speaks the language of disease. The patient's words speak the language of illness. This book argues that medicine needs both, and it is a useful outside companion to Aphorism 7.

    Read it with one question in mind: which of Kleinman's two categories does Hahnemann's "totality of symptoms" belong to? The honest answer may be that it does not fit neatly into either, which is worth a classroom discussion.

1 REFLECTION

 

I do not think advancing diagnostic technology diminishes Hahnemann's proposition. If anything, it gives us another reason to revisit it, question our understanding and refine our clinical thinking.

The purpose of medical knowledge should not be to make us increasingly certain of what we already know, but to make us increasingly aware of what we have yet to understand.

 

Perhaps the most important question is not how far inside we can see, but whether seeing further has made us understand more.

 

That is a question worth keeping alive in every clinical classroom.

 

Until next Week,

Dr. E.S. Khan

BHMS, MD (Hom.) | AFHom London |

Associate Professor

Organon of Medicine, Metropolitan Homoeopathic Medical College, Kolkata

OrganonEasy · Private Practice 

 


If this resonated, subscribe and forward it to one colleague who thinks carefully about homoeopathy.

 

If you would like to unsubscribe, please click here.

Sent using Sender.net