‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ 
Is this email not displaying correctly? View it in your browser.
Image description

December 2021

SEFI Ethics Special Interest Group Newsletter

Coming up in this month’s newsletter

Dear reader,


In our previous two seminars we brought to attention the theme of water and responsible engineering, through an online seminar that gathered together Yanna Lambrinidou (Virginia Tech, USA), Neelke Doorn (TU Delft, The Netherlands), Edmond Byrne (University College Cork, Ireland) and Rafael Ziegler (HEC Montréal, Canada), followed by a workshop dedicated to STS postures held by Nicole Mogul and David Tomblin (Science, Technology and Society: University of Maryland College Park). Our December newsletter includes various ethical, cultural and socio-political perspectives about the importance of considering water in engineering education as well as themes that may serve as inspiration for engineering instructors. This is the final newsletter of a rich year, and we want to thank the entire SEFI community for being with us throughout the many events we organized. 2021 has proved that engineering ethics education has many friends, in many parts of the world.

The Chinese philosopher Lao Tzu in the sixth century B.C. wrote:

There is nothing softer and weaker than water,
And yet there is nothing better for attacking hard and strong things.
For this reason there is no substitute for it.
All the world knows that the weak overcomes the strong and the soft overcomes the hard.
But none can practice it.

Tao-te Ching ch. 78, translation Wing-Tsit Chan

As we see this, it is close to what ethics is. Ethics also is soft and flexible, but can have a huge impact on reality.

Image description

Edmond Byrne in Urban water provision; Engineering considerations and Ethical [Framings,] for example, explains how being explicit about different world views will open up to different engineering interventions. Many interventions are stuck into large scale engineering involving increasing supply to meet growing demand. Students easily stay within the confines framed by the engineering report through their presentations. Explicit attention to different world views opens up to critical thinking and transdisciplinary approaches.

Image description

Ben Pauli in Rethinking Success and Failure in Community-Oriented Engineering gives a strong example of how the self-image of engineers influences what is considered and communicated as success. The contribution describes how in Flint, a majority African-American US city with over 40% of its population living under the poverty line, had elevated levels of lead found in the drinking water of residences. This is described as an engineering failure. But the contribution goes on to describe how a water sampling collaboration between Flint activists and community-oriented engineers volunteering its time, resources, and expertise. This team considered their contributions as a success, whereas the citizens themselves did not…

Image description

Ricki Levi and Daniel Mishori’s contribution TEK and the Challenge of a “Broad” Water Ethics is inspired by Anupam Mishra and complements Ben Pauli’s conclusions when they plea for what they call “Gandhian values of simplicity, solidarity, mutual-dependence, TEK (traditional ecological knowledge), and commons-based resource management.” They put forward a holistic ethical perspective of water.

Image description

This view is supported by Ingrid Leman Stefanovic, who in Why Engineers should care about Water Ethics explores how moral questions have received comparatively little attention in the decision-making frameworks that dominate water policy and management.

Image description

David Groenfeldt in his contribution A Water Ethics Framework for Engineers applies this to the micro-level, discussing how an ethical reflection in a village pilot project to introduce solar irrigation in Bihar, India led to "solar irrigation service providers" that lowered inequalities and local market deregulations.

Image description

Ilmas Futehally in Water Cooperation Quotient- An Engineering Perspective applies this to the macro-level, explaining how the availability of water influences wars between riparian countries. The contribution mentions the Strategic Foresight Group conclusion that “Any two countries engaged in active water cooperation do not go to war for any reason.” This is illustrated by the Grand Ethiopian Renaissance Dam (GERD) on the Blue Nile, and that, if from the beginning an ethical approach of cooperation and joint decision making had been made, much before the construction had started, the current impasse and near war between Egypt and Ethiopia would not have been reached.

Image description

These examples all lead to the same conclusion that Sarah Cotterill makes in Creating space for ethical discussion in environmental engineering education: We can embed much stronger links with sustainability and ethics throughout our engineering ethics education modules, ensuring technical or numerical content is framed within context to make it relatable.

Image description

This will lead, according to us, to a (water) ethics that is like water: soft, flexible and impactful.


Thank you for being with us and we wish you all the best for 2022,


Gunter Bombaerts and Diana Martin

Invitation: SEFI SIG Ethics online seminar series

Our upcoming online workshop is dedicated to the topic of promoting STS postures. We hope to see you, by registering at the following link! Please check your spam folder if you haven’t received the registration info, or contact Diana ([email protected]).

Wednesday, 15 December, 16-18 CET / 10-12 EST


Speakers: Glen Miller (Texas A&M University, USA), Alexandra Kazakova (Gubkin Russian State University, Russia), Satya Sundar Sethy (Indian Institute of Technology Madras, India) Qin Zhu, (Colorado School of Mines, USA)



The seminar will bring to the forefront the question of what it means to teach engineering ethics in a global manner and share perspectives on the teaching of ethics from diverse cultural contexts. Speakers will explore issues ranging from the impact of a dominant culture that is manifest in engineering ethics education to examples on how to broaden the teaching of ethics in a culturally inclusive manner.

Register here

Thursday, 20 January 2022 3pm – 5pm CET/ 9am - 11pm EST


Speakers: Aida Guerra (Aalborg University), André Baier (TU Berlin), Jordi Segalàs (Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya), Jonathan Truslove (Engineers Without Borders UK)


SEFI acknowledges the importance of bringing to the attention of engineering students themes related to sustainable development. The seminar explores innovative approaches to implementing and teaching sustainability in the engineering curriculum.



Participation in the seminar is free and open to all. To attend, please register at the following link. Please check your spam folder if you haven’t received the confirmation with the link to the event.



Interested to speak at one of our next seminars or propose a theme for discussion? Feel welcome to contact the seminar series’ organizer Diana ([email protected]).

Register here

If you wish to propose a theme for a future ethics seminar, or are interested in organizing such a seminar yourself, please contact Diana ([email protected]).

Call for Submissions for the SEFI Ethics Alpine Retreat 2022 -

Engineering ethics education and social justice: synthesis and growth

31st March - 1st April 2022 - Location: either (a) a hybrid event (online and onsite) in the Swiss Alps or (b) fully online (tbc)



The SEFI Ethics Special Interest Group is organising a one and a half day workshop on engineering ethics education, and invites those interested to submit suggestions for workshops or papers. Please submit a short expression of interest (200 words) to [email protected] by 16th January 2022.


Approach: The spring school is intended to maximise opportunities for interaction, discussion and exchange. While papers are welcome, workshops which prioritise exchange and discussion on a theme will be prioritised, along with sessions dedicated to small group meetings and dialogue.


Theme: Engineering ethics education is often described as addressing two domains: a micro-ethics domain which focuses on individual responsibility and day to day decision-making, and a macro-ethics domain which addresses the social and environmental impact of engineering as a profession including a focus on sustainability and social justice. Notwithstanding differences across global regions as to how engineering ethics is designed and taught, the dominant trend has, until recently, perhaps tended to focus more on micro issues than on macro ethics.


At the same time, engineering ethics education has perhaps never has as much diversity as it has today. In the last year the SEFI ethics seminars have addressed a wide range of themes including emotional aspects of engineering ethics, ethics in design, social justice issues, as well as a rich array of ethics teaching methods (case studies, film, and fiction).

At this time too, events outside engineering and education such Black Lives Matter, #MeToo, the Coronavirus Pandemic, political realignment in many countries, and attacks on expertise and scientific knowledge, raises questions about how the macro and the micro are connected in engineering ethics education, and about the methods and approaches appropriate for ethics education with engineers.


The alpine retreat will give a space for those interested in the topic of engineering ethics education, to map out, combine, and generate new approaches to practicing micro and macro engineering ethics education.


Possible themes include:

  • Freedom of expression and teaching ethics in a safe space

  • Engineering Ethics in a new hybrid world

  • Engineering Ethics and Social Equality/Social Justice

  • Emotions and social justice in Engineering Ethics Education

  • Building participation/engagement in the international engineering ethics education community

  • Making sense and proposing/sharing ethics values to/with students

Participants can feel free to suggest other themes and topics which may lie outside these strands.


For more information, please contact the organizer Roland at [email protected]

News and initiatives

Videorecordings of SEFI SIG Ethics webinars: are now available to watch on the themes of Water and responsible engineering and STS postures.

Environmental Ethics - A Sourcebook for Educators aims to providing practical material for instructors to begin incorporating ethics as an everyday activity into their teaching. All the chapters in the book introduce different pedagogical approaches for bringing ethics to the fore in environmental education. The activities are all structured around a theme or series of themes and subthemes. They all begin with a short introduction to each theme that contextualises the inherent issues and identifies some pertinent observations and questions. The introductions are followed by concrete activities. Some activity sections also include extension activities. Some extensions allow teachers and learners to adapt the activities to their own schools or communities. Others are designed to be conducted over longer periods of time. The sourcebook is co-authored by Bob Jickling (Lakehead University Canada), Heila Lotz-Sisitka, Lausanne Olvitt, Rob O’Donoghue, Ingrid Schudel, Dylan McGarry (all from Rhodes University, South Africa) and Blair Niblett (Trent University’s School of Education, Canada) and can be downloaded for free at the following link.

International Ethics in Chemistry: Developing Common Values across Cultures. Susan M. Schelble (Metropolitan State University of Denver, United States) and Kelly M. Elkins (Towson University, United States) edited a volume exploring ethical issues across chemistry, focusing on chemical organizations and researchers and how they establish policies and educational strategies for professional ethics. Chapters focus on intellectual property, codes of conduct, relationships with employers and government, and safety in the laboratory and workplace. By viewing both the past and future, readers will find shared ethical best practices to address international challenges with enormous effects on human and planetary health. The volume is motivated by the need to reconcile cultural differences to share scientific information in the global scientific practice. More information is available at the following link.

Cultural inclusiveness at REES 2021: The organisers of the conference and REEN board undertook active efforts to promote cultural inclusiveness and non-main stream perspectives. The conference facilitated participation for those in different timezones, and included several papers and workshops of interest to the community of ethics educators, which addressed aboriginal perspectives, recentering local knowledge, how to ensure a culturally relevant pedagogy, developing intersectional inclusion capabilities or building cultural intelligence, as well as contributions which challenged popular western-centric trends such as the focus on fostering GRIT. REES AAEE 2021 was organised by The University of Western Australia and all papers are available at the following link.

Open calls - Upcoming events

SEFI SiG Ethics Workshop: Engineering education for sustainability

Thursday, 20 January 2022 3pm – 5pm CET/ 9am - 11pm EST – Registration

SEFI SiG Alpine retreat: Engineering ethics education and social justice: synthesis and growth

Dates: 31st March - 1st April 2022 – Info

Expressions of interest and session proposals welcome until 16 Jan 2022 at [email protected]

The Boston University Graduate Student Philosophy Conference: Sustainability and Environmental Ethics

21-22 April 2022, Boston, USA

Call for papers (dl 18 December 2021)

The 22nd ASEE Annual Conference and Exposition

26-29 June 2022, Minneapolis, USA - Call for abstracts (dl 8 February 2022)

Recent articles and publications

Recent publications and articles dedicated to engineering ethics education are now available on our website. 

The Ethics SIG Newsletter is issued 10 times per year and aims to share information on latest engineering ethics research and practices. If you would like to join the mailing list please use the form on the SEFI Ethics SIG website.


If you have something you want to share in the newsletter (great ideas, upcoming workshops, nice experiences …), let us know: Diana ([email protected]) and Gunter ([email protected]) Or connect with us on Twitter using #SefiEthics to signal publications, initiatives or events for inclusion in the newsletter

SEFI thanks its corporate partners for their support:

Image description
Image description
Image description
Image description
Image description

SEFI aisbl

39, rue des Deux Eglises
1000 Brussels

Facebook icon
Twitter icon
Instagram icon
Facebook icon

[email protected]

+32 2 502 36 09
www.sefi.be

Data protection policy for our MembersStakeholder ContactsSuppliersEmployees

If you want to unsubscribe, click here.
Sender.net